Reviewed by the TrustedBuyerReport editorial team. This guide was drafted with AI assistance and is based on manufacturer pricing, verified customer reviews aggregated from Trustpilot and other platforms, and publicly available product data. TrustedBuyerReport may earn a commission when you use our links to make a purchase.
Yes, Bullymake is worth it — but only for the right dog. If yours destroys a $20 toy in 20 minutes, the math tips hard in Bullymake's favor. If your dog's a casual chewer who's happy with a squeaky from Target, it's probably overkill. Here's the full breakdown so you can decide in 60 seconds.
What Is Bullymake, and What Do You Actually Get?
Bullymake is a monthly subscription box built specifically for power chewers — think pit bulls, Rottweilers, German Shepherds, and any dog that treats regular toys like a five-minute snack.
Each box includes one of two configurations:
- Toys + Treats box: 2–3 durable toys + 3 bags of USA-made treats
- Toys Only box: 4–5 tough toys, no treats (good for dogs with food sensitivities)
Toy materials include nylon, dense rubber, ballistic fabric, and rope. Monthly themes keep the lineup fresh. You can also customize by toy type — nylon only, rubber only, or a mix — and flag dietary restrictions for the treat add-ons.
One standout feature: a 45-day replacement guarantee. If a toy is destroyed within 45 days of delivery, Bullymake replaces it for free — no receipts, no return shipping.
Bullymake Pricing: Every Tier, Explained
Bullymake's cost per box depends on which subscription plan you choose. Here's how it breaks down currently:
| Plan | Price Per Box | Billed |
|---|---|---|
| Month-to-month | ~$45/mo | Monthly |
| 3-month | ~$36/mo | Upfront |
| 6-month | ~$34/mo | Upfront |
| 12-month | ~$29/mo | Upfront |
Prices are consistent with what Bullymake publishes on their subscription page. First-time subscriber discounts are frequently available — worth checking before you commit to a full year.
Bottom line on pricing: The 12-month plan is the best per-box value at around $29/month, but it requires paying upfront (~$348). The month-to-month option gives you flexibility at ~$45/month — about $16 more per box, which adds up over time.
The Cost Per Toy Breakdown (This Is Where It Gets Interesting)
This is the number most Bullymake reviews skip. Let's actually do the math.
Toys + Treats Box — month-to-month ($45/mo)
With 2 toys per box:
- Cost per toy: $22.50
- Equivalent retail price for a comparable durable toy: $20–$25
- Add: 3 bags of USA-made treats (retail value roughly $6–$10 each)
- Estimated treat value: $18–$30
So you're paying $45 and getting toys at or near retail — and getting $18–$30 in treats on top.
With 3 toys in the box, the per-toy cost drops to $15, which is well below what you'd pay for comparable nylon or rubber chew toys at Chewy or PetSmart.
Toys Only Box — month-to-month ($45/mo)
With 4–5 toys per box:
- Cost per toy: $9–$11
- Comparable retail price: $15–$25 per toy
At the Toys Only tier, you're getting purpose-built power-chewer toys at roughly half the retail price per unit. That's a meaningful saving if your dog actually engages with all 4–5 toys.
12-Month Subscription — Toys Only ($29/mo)
- Cost per toy (4–5 toys): $5.80–$7.25
- Retail equivalent: $15–$25 per toy
At this level, the value is hard to argue with — assuming your dog will use everything in the box.
How Does Bullymake Compare to Buying Toys Individually?
Here's the honest comparison based on retail data from Chewy and PetSmart.
A durable nylon bone (like a Nylabone Power Chew) typically runs $16–$22. A heavy-duty rubber chew toy in the Kong Extreme tier runs $12–$25 depending on size. Ballistic fabric toys for large breeds regularly hit $20+.
If a typical power-chewer household buys 2–3 new toys per month to replace destroyed ones, that's $30–$75 per month at retail — before treats, before gas, before the frustration of finding something your dog won't gut in 10 minutes.
A Toys + Treats Bullymake box at $34–$45 covers that range comfortably, with the added benefit of being selected for durability by default.
The one scenario where retail wins: If your dog has very specific toy preferences (say, only rubber, only a certain size) and Bullymake keeps sending the wrong type, the per-toy value disappears fast. That's where the customization options matter — set your preferences before box #1, not after box #3.
What Real Subscribers Say: Patterns Across 1,900+ Reviews
This guide is based on publicly available customer feedback aggregated from Bullymake's Trustpilot profile (4.4 stars, 1,900+ reviews as of mid-2026), their own review page, and third-party review roundups. TrustedBuyerReport has not independently tested Bullymake products.
The consistent wins:
- Toys outlast comparable pet store toys by weeks to months for most power chewers
- Monthly themes and variety keep dogs noticeably more engaged
- Customization (nylon-only, rubber-only, toy-swap requests) is genuinely flexible
- Replacement guarantee has a strong reputation for actually being honored
The consistent complaints:
- Auto-renewal catches some subscribers off guard — the terms are stated upfront, but easy to miss
- Rope toys are frequently flagged as the weak link; several reviewers note their dogs tear through them quickly
- Customer service wait times can be long during peak periods
- Not ideal for small dogs or light chewers — the toys skew large and hard
One honest note from the reviews: A small but consistent group of reviewers reports that even Bullymake's toughest toys don't survive their dog's first session. No toy is truly indestructible, and the 45-day replacement guarantee is there for exactly this reason. If your dog is in that extreme tier, the guarantee is the feature you're really paying for.
Is Bullymake Worth It for Your Specific Situation?
Bullymake makes the most sense if:
- Your dog destroys standard toys within days
- You're spending $30+ per month replacing toys anyway
- You want the convenience of curated, durability-focused toy rotation without researching every purchase
- Your dog is a medium-to-large breed (50+ lbs)
Consider skipping it if:
- Your dog is a light or moderate chewer — standard toys already last months
- Your dog is very picky about toy type and dislikes surprises
- You have a small dog (under 25 lbs) — most Bullymake toys are sized for bigger breeds
- You prefer hand-picking every toy your dog receives
If you're on the fence and want to compare it to other subscription options for dogs, our best pet subscription boxes guide covers the full field — including how Bullymake stacks up against BarkBox and other alternatives.
Bullymake vs. BarkBox: The 30-Second Version
BarkBox is the more popular brand, but it's not built for power chewers. Their standard box includes plush toys that most aggressive chewers will gut in minutes. BarkBox's Super Chewer tier is a more direct comparison — but Bullymake's entire catalog is designed for heavy chewing from the start, without needing to upgrade tiers.
If your dog is a light-to-moderate chewer, BarkBox wins on variety and price. If your dog destroys anything not made of nylon or heavy rubber, Bullymake is the more targeted choice.
The Bottom Line: Is Bullymake Worth the Price?
For owners of true power chewers, yes — Bullymake typically delivers per-toy costs of $9–$22 depending on the plan and box type, against retail prices of $15–$25 for comparable durable toys. Add the treat value and the replacement guarantee, and the math holds up.
The 12-month Toys Only plan is the best value on paper ($5.80–$7.25 per toy), but only makes sense if your dog reliably engages with a variety of toy types. The month-to-month Toys + Treats box is the safer starting point — you can always downgrade or optimize once you know what your dog actually uses.
For a broader look at pet products reviewed in 2026, including toys, training gear, and food, check our full roundup. If you're also shopping for better food to pair with your dog's enrichment routine, our vet-recommended dog food guide is worth a look.
Ready to try it? Check current Bullymake pricing and start your subscription here — or browse our Bullymake store page for any active discount codes before you commit.
Frequently Asked Questions
How many toys come in a Bullymake box?
The Toys + Treats box includes 2–3 toys plus 3 bags of treats. The Toys Only box includes 4–5 toys with no treats. Box size is selected based on your dog's weight.
Does Bullymake work for small dogs?
Bullymake is primarily designed for medium-to-large power chewers. While they do size toys by weight, many reviewers with smaller dogs (under 25 lbs) find the toys are too large or too hard for their pet's comfort. For small dogs, it's worth contacting Bullymake's customer service before subscribing to confirm sizing options.
What is Bullymake's replacement policy?
If a toy is destroyed within 45 days of delivery, Bullymake will send a replacement at no charge. Based on customer reviews, this policy has a strong reputation for being honored without friction.
Can you cancel Bullymake anytime?
Month-to-month subscribers can cancel before the next billing date. Multi-month plans (3, 6, or 12 months) are billed upfront, so cancellation stops future charges but doesn't refund the current committed period. Read the terms on the Bullymake FAQ page before choosing a plan length.
Is Bullymake good for training?
Bullymake focuses on enrichment toys and chews, not training-specific gear. If you're working on obedience or behavioral issues, check out our best pet training tools guide for tools that pair well with a structured training program.
How does Bullymake compare to buying from Chewy?
Chewy offers a wide range of individual durable toys, often with auto-ship discounts. The tradeoff: you're doing the research and selecting each toy yourself. Bullymake's value is in the curation — every item is pre-screened for power-chewer durability, and the monthly theme rotation provides variety without the shopping overhead. Our Chewy review covers when Chewy's auto-ship is the smarter move.
We may earn a commission from purchases made through links on this page. This article was drafted with AI assistance and reviewed by the TrustedBuyerReport editorial team.
