Bullymake is a monthly dog toy subscription box service designed specifically for power chewers and aggressive chewing dogs. Available at bullymake.com, each box ships directly to your door and includes 2-3 tough toys and 3 healthy treats made in the USA, all built around a fun monthly theme that changes every month.
The brand offers five toy material types to suit different play styles: Nylon (the toughest, rated to withstand 3,500+ PSI), Rubber (bouncy and treat-holding, the second toughest), Rope (100% cotton for tug-of-war), Ballistic (crinkle-fabric for interactive play), and Plush (soft and squeaky for gentler chewers). Subscribers can customize their box to match their dog's chewing style, and even select a toys-only option with 4 toys per month and no treats.
Bullymake accommodates dogs with beef, chicken, and grain allergies, with allergy preferences settable during sign-up or updated anytime via the subscriber account portal. The intro offer is priced at $19 for the first box, which also includes free poop bags. This low entry price makes it easy to test the service before committing to a full subscription cycle.
The brand backs its products with a 45-day satisfaction guarantee: if any toy is destroyed or unsuitable within 45 days of receipt, subscribers can contact customer care with a photo and receive a free replacement toy of a different type (limit one per month). This guarantee applies only to US purchasers buying from authorized retailers, and replacements are toys — not monetary refunds.
It is worth noting that Bullymake holds a BBB rating of D- (though it is BBB-accredited), and both the shipping policy and return policy pages currently return 404 errors on the website, making it difficult to verify standard shipping times or a formal returns process. Trustpilot ratings are not available at this time. Prospective subscribers are advised to contact customer support directly at customercare@bullymake.com for policy clarification before subscribing.