If your dog has destroyed every toy you've ever bought — sometimes within minutes — you've probably wondered whether Bullymake is any different. The short answer: for true power chewers, it's one of the few subscription boxes that actually delivers on durability. But it isn't for every dog or every budget, and there are real trade-offs worth knowing before you commit.
Here's everything you need to know, based on aggregated owner feedback, verified specs, and a direct comparison with competing options.
Quick verdict: Bullymake is the best dog subscription box for large-breed power chewers — think Pitbulls, Rottweilers, Cane Corsos, and Mastiffs. If your dog shreds standard toys in under 30 minutes, this is one of the only services built for that. If your dog is a moderate chewer or under 25 lbs, there are better-value alternatives.
What Is Bullymake?
Bullymake is a monthly dog subscription box founded in 2014, built specifically for power chewers. Unlike general-purpose dog boxes that bundle plush toys with treats, Bullymake focuses almost entirely on structural durability — toys made from nylon, reinforced rubber, ballistic fabric, and heavy-duty rope.
The key differentiator: Bullymake manufactures most of its toys in-house and in the USA. That matters because the design is driven by chew testing, not just aesthetics. Their nylon toys, in particular, are engineered to withstand over 3,500 PSI — roughly four times the bite force of even the strongest dog breeds.
Every box ships monthly with a unique seasonal or holiday theme. You get 2–3 toys plus 3 full-size bags of grain-free treats (toys-and-treats box), or 4–5 toys if you opt for the toys-only configuration.
Bullymake Pricing Breakdown (2026)
Bullymake offers 1-, 3-, 6-, and 12-month subscription plans. Longer commitments reduce the per-box price, with discounts of up to 20% on annual plans.
| Plan | Price Range | Commitment | Cancel Policy |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1-Month | ~$45/month | None | Cancel anytime |
| 3-Month | ~$37–$40/month | 3 boxes | Must complete term |
| 6-Month | ~$33–$36/month | 6 boxes | Must complete term |
| 12-Month | ~$29–$32/month | 12 boxes | Must complete term |
First-box deal: New subscribers frequently see introductory offers around $19 for the first box, or up to 40% off their first shipment. These are worth watching for on Bullymake's subscribe page.
One honest note on cost: the 3-, 6-, and 12-month plans require you to complete your commitment before canceling. If you're not sure, start with the monthly plan — it's more expensive per box but carries zero risk.
What's Inside a Bullymake Box?
Each box is built around a monthly theme (holidays, seasons, pop culture). Here's what you actually receive:
Toys & Treats box: 2–3 heavy-duty toys + 3 full-size treat bags Toys-only box: 4–5 toys (no treats, ideal for dogs with dietary sensitivities)
Toy materials available:
- Nylon — Solid single-piece construction, no stuffing. Leaves bite marks and surface wear, which is normal and expected. Best for extreme chewers.
- Rubber — Slightly more give than nylon. Works well for most power chewers, but dogs with extreme jaw strength (Pitbull mixes, Mastiffs) may work through these faster.
- Ballistic fabric — Dense, reinforced textile. Satisfies dogs that like to tug and tear without creating hazardous loose pieces.
- Rope — The softest option in the lineup. Multiple owner reviews note rope toys tend to get destroyed faster than the harder materials. Good for tugging but not for solo chewing sessions.
You choose your preferred toy type after purchase through your account dashboard. You can also set allergy preferences for treats (beef, chicken, grain).
Toy Durability: What Owners Actually Report
This is the core question, and the honest answer is that durability varies by toy type and your dog's chewing intensity.
Nylon toys: Consistently rated most durable across owner feedback. Multiple multi-year subscribers report nylon toys still intact after months of use with large breeds.
Rubber toys: Durable for most dogs, but aggressive chewers — especially at 50 lbs+ — sometimes work through them in under an hour. If your dog is an extreme rubber destroyer, switching to a nylon-only configuration is the smarter move.
Rope toys: The weakest link. Several owners specifically called out rope toys as the first to go. If rope is in your box and your dog is a serious chewer, you may want to swap this preference in your account settings.
The guarantee: If a toy is destroyed within 14 days, Bullymake will send a free replacement — a harder, tougher version better suited for your dog's chew level. This serves as a self-calibrating system: the first replacement box is often more durable than the first.
In 2026, Bullymake also updated to a 45-day satisfaction guarantee covering not just broken toys but overall satisfaction with any item.
Customization Options
Bullymake's customization is narrower than some competitors but deeper in what matters for its target audience.
You can customize:
- Toy material type (nylon, rubber, ballistic, rope — or a mix)
- Box type (toys + treats vs. toys only)
- Allergy preferences (beef, chicken, grain)
- Delivery frequency (monthly, every 2 months, every 3 months)
You cannot customize:
- Specific toy designs or themes — the monthly theme is set
- Treat flavors beyond allergy categories
For dogs with complex dietary needs, the toys-only option is a solid fallback. If you're managing multiple dogs with different chew intensities, several owners report successfully running separate subscriptions at different material settings.
Bullymake vs. BarkBox Super Chewer
If you've been comparing these two, here's the direct breakdown:
| Factor | Bullymake | BarkBox Super Chewer |
|---|---|---|
| Best for | Large breeds, extreme chewers | Medium-large dogs, committed chewers |
| Toy construction | Solid nylon/rubber, no stuffing | Can include fabric elements |
| Toy variety | Narrower, durability-focused | More variety, enrichment-focused |
| Small dog fit | Poor (under 25 lbs) | Better — sizes for small/medium/large |
| Pricing (annual) | ~$29–32/month + ~$4 shipping | Similar per box, free shipping on contiguous US |
| Guarantee | 14-day toy replacement + 45-day satisfaction | More flexible replacement policy |
| Cancellation | Must complete multi-month terms | Must complete term before canceling |
The practical decision rule: if your dog has already destroyed BarkBox Super Chewer toys, Bullymake is the logical next step. BarkBox Super Chewer works better for dogs who are strong chewers but not extreme destroyers.
If you're still exploring pet subscription options, our roundup of the best pet subscription boxes in 2026 compares Bullymake alongside BarkBox, KitNipBox, and others to help you find the right fit.
What Owners Praise Most
Aggregated from verified customer reviews across Trustpilot and Bullymake's own review pages (rated 4.4/5 on Trustpilot with approximately 2,000 reviews as of 2026):
Most common positives:
- Toys outlast anything bought at a pet store or on Amazon for the same price range
- Customer service is fast and the toy replacement guarantee is honored without friction
- Box customization feels meaningful — especially the toys-only option and material preferences
- USA-made toys and treats are a significant trust factor for many owners
- The themed unboxing experience creates genuine excitement — many owners report their dogs recognize the orange box
The Real Complaints
Rope toys don't hold up. This is the most consistent criticism. If your dog is a serious chewer, exclude rope from your preferences.
Subscription terms are locked in. On 3-, 6-, and 12-month plans, you can't cancel mid-commitment. Some owners were caught off guard by the auto-renewal after the initial term ended. Read the terms carefully before committing to a longer plan.
Shipping cost on longer plans. Bullymake charges approximately $4/month for shipping on multi-month plans. BarkBox Super Chewer ships free to the contiguous US, so the actual annual cost difference is smaller than the listed price suggests.
Not ideal for small dogs. Toy dimensions are built for medium-to-large breeds. Dogs under 20–25 lbs may struggle to engage with the toys. Rubber toys in particular can be too dense for smaller jaws to find satisfying.
Is Bullymake Worth It?
Get Bullymake if:
- Your dog is a Pitbull, Rottweiler, Cane Corso, Mastiff, Bulldog, German Shepherd, or similar large power-chewing breed
- Your dog destroys standard store-bought toys within hours
- You want USA-made toys and treats with transparent ingredients
- You prefer a toys-only configuration for a dog with dietary restrictions
- You value a durability guarantee that actually gets honored
Skip Bullymake if:
- Your dog weighs under 25 lbs or is a light-to-moderate chewer
- You want flexibility to cancel without finishing a commitment (start month-to-month if unsure)
- You want a box with collars, accessories, or non-toy items beyond treats
- Budget is tight and you can't commit to $29–$45/month consistently
How Does Bullymake Compare to Buying Toys Individually?
A single nylon or heavy-duty rubber dog toy at most pet stores costs $15–$25. Bullymake packs an estimated retail value of $50+ per box, including 2–3 toys and 3 treat bags. For owners who were already spending $60–$80/month replacing cheap toys that broke in days, the subscription often works out cheaper per durable toy.
For context on how Bullymake fits into a broader pet care budget, it's worth comparing against what you're spending at Chewy or PetSmart for individual toys — the math often tilts in Bullymake's favor once you factor in toy lifespan.
How to Get Started
- Visit Bullymake's site and select your plan (1, 3, 6, or 12 months)
- Enter your dog's details — name, allergies, toy preferences
- Choose your box type — toys + treats, or toys only
- Set toy material preferences in your account after purchase
Your first box ships the next business day, then every 30 days after that.
👉 Start your Bullymake subscription here — check the current new subscriber offer before you sign up.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Bullymake work for puppies? Bullymake is designed for power chewers, not puppy-specific enrichment. Puppies with strong chewing instincts can use it, but younger pups (under 6 months) may do better with softer options. If your puppy is already destroying everything, the rubber material setting is a reasonable starting point.
Can I pause or skip a month? Yes. You can adjust delivery frequency (monthly, every 2 months, every 3 months) by contacting customer support at customercare@bullymake.com or via live chat on the site.
Does Bullymake ship internationally? Bullymake ships to Canada and Australia, but treats are excluded from those shipments — you'll automatically receive the toys-only box configuration.
What if my dog has food allergies? Set allergy preferences (beef, chicken, or grain) in your account after purchase. The toys-only option is the safest fallback for dogs with complex sensitivities.
Are Bullymake toys actually indestructible? No toy is truly indestructible for every dog — Bullymake doesn't claim that either. What they do guarantee: if a toy is destroyed within 14 days, you get a free replacement with a harder material. Their nylon toys withstand over 3,500 PSI in testing, which exceeds the bite force of any domesticated breed.
How does Bullymake compare to training-focused enrichment tools? Bullymake is primarily about durability and play. If you're looking to pair physical enrichment with behavior training, our guide to the best pet training tools and online courses in 2026 covers options that complement a subscription box routine well.
Reviewed by the Trusted Buyer Report editorial team. We aggregate verified customer feedback, manufacturer specifications, and expert analysis to help you make better purchasing decisions. Trusted Buyer Report may earn a commission from purchases made through links on this page.
